Jon W. Hansen, FCIPS | Procurement Insights | Hansen Models™
Adriana Lobo opens her new article in ISM’s Inside Supply Management, “The Landed Cost Model Your Team Can Actually Build” (November 2026), with a line every procurement leader should read twice: “Buying at US$10 to sell at $15 does not produce $5.”
It produces whatever is left after freight, duties, brokerage, insurance, financing, quality failures and the cost of carrying more stock than you needed. Her point is that most of those costs never appear on the purchase order, so the buyer believes the margin is there until the invoices arrive.
When I read it, it jumped off the page, because I have seen that exact arithmetic before.
1998: The margin that wasn’t there
In 1998, SHL SystemHouse, then part of MCI, was managing the MRO parts procurement for Canada’s Department of National Defence. The contract called for 90 percent next-day delivery. They were delivering 51 percent.
Tracing back from the missed deliveries took us well beyond procurement. Most of the work was going to small U.S. suppliers with no experience clearing goods across the border, each using its own courier. And when we reached finance, we found the same gap Adriana describes.
The purchase orders captured the cost of the part. The courier charges were invoiced separately. The markup was calculated on the part cost alone. So on most transactions, the shipping ate the margin. Every number in the system was accurate. Nothing in the system added them together.
Nobody had hidden anything. The part cost lived in procurement, the courier bill lived in finance, and the customs delays lived at the border. Each department saw its own line. Nobody saw the sum.
2003: The same finding, a different company
In 2003, when the Ottawa Business Journal profiled my company at the time, E-Procure Solutions, I described the market we were serving in almost the same terms: high-tech companies were spending so much time chasing replacement parts that the process of getting a part often cost more than the part itself.
Different company, different year, same gap between price and cost.
2026: Still here
Now it is 2026. We have cloud platforms, real-time analytics and AI agents that can place orders on their own. And a practitioner with a clear view of the market is still having to explain to procurement teams that the price is not the cost.
That is not a criticism of Adriana’s article. It is the reason her article matters. The gap between price and cost is not a problem one generation of technology solves and the next one forgets. It is a constant. It comes back with every new system, because every new system is built on the same documents: the purchase order, the invoice, the quote. The hidden costs live between those documents, in the seams.
What her model does, and what lies beneath it
Adriana’s answer is practical, and it works. Build a simple landed cost model, one row per cost element. Where you don’t have a number, write down a stated assumption instead of leaving a blank. Apply the same assumptions to every supplier. Most important, build it before the negotiation, not after the invoice, so that payment terms, order size and quality become negotiating topics alongside price.
There is one more layer underneath, and it starts with how prices behave.
In 2007, I wrote in Dangerous Supply Chain Myths (Part 7) that commodities fall into one of two patterns. A Historic Flat Line commodity holds a steady price over long periods, with a narrow gap between its lowest and highest price. Direct materials and specialty equipment behave this way. A Dynamic Flux commodity swings sharply and keeps drifting down over time, with a wide gap between its floor and its ceiling. MRO and other indirect materials behave this way. Flat-line commodities usually account for about 80 percent of an organization’s spend and 10 percent of its procurement cycle time. Flux commodities account, on average, for 15 to 20 percent of spend and 90 percent of the cycle time.
The trouble starts when both are bought the same way. A contract price negotiated at signing works for a flat-line item, because the market stays close to it. For a flux item, the market keeps falling away beneath the contract, until the contract price sits above the market’s own ceiling. That is why buyers so often say they can beat the contract price with one phone call to a local supplier.
And within a single day, a flux item can be bought near its floor or near its ceiling. 1998 showed us what decides which one you get.
At DND, the same part from the same supplier could cost up to nine times as much when it was ordered at 4 p.m. as when it was ordered at 9 a.m. The reason was not on any quote. The service technicians were measured on call volume, and stopping to order a part interrupted a service call, so they held their part orders until late afternoon. By then, the suppliers’ day was nearly over, the courier cutoffs were close, and the price and the delivery both suffered.
No landed cost model would have found that cost, because it didn’t belong to any supplier. Every quote carried it equally. The ranking of suppliers was right. The total was wrong.
So there are three tiers. The obvious costs sit on documents someone already receives. The hidden costs, which Adriana lays out, are real and quantifiable but attached to no single document. And beneath both are the costs created by how and when the organization buys. Her model makes the first two visible before the negotiation. Tracing back from the outcome finds the third.
The question to take back
Pick one category you buy every week. What does it cost you, not what is it priced at, and which part of that cost doesn’t appear on any document?
If the answer surprises you, you are in good company. It surprised SHL SystemHouse in 1998. It is still surprising teams in 2026.
Truth Is Believing. Accuracy Is Knowing. Outcome Is Proof.™
Buying at $10 to Sell at $15 Doesn’t Produce $5. It Didn’t in 1998 Either.
Posted on November 19, 2026
0
Jon W. Hansen, FCIPS | Procurement Insights | Hansen Models™
Adriana Lobo opens her new article in ISM’s Inside Supply Management, “The Landed Cost Model Your Team Can Actually Build” (November 2026), with a line every procurement leader should read twice: “Buying at US$10 to sell at $15 does not produce $5.”
It produces whatever is left after freight, duties, brokerage, insurance, financing, quality failures and the cost of carrying more stock than you needed. Her point is that most of those costs never appear on the purchase order, so the buyer believes the margin is there until the invoices arrive.
When I read it, it jumped off the page, because I have seen that exact arithmetic before.
1998: The margin that wasn’t there
In 1998, SHL SystemHouse, then part of MCI, was managing the MRO parts procurement for Canada’s Department of National Defence. The contract called for 90 percent next-day delivery. They were delivering 51 percent.
Tracing back from the missed deliveries took us well beyond procurement. Most of the work was going to small U.S. suppliers with no experience clearing goods across the border, each using its own courier. And when we reached finance, we found the same gap Adriana describes.
The purchase orders captured the cost of the part. The courier charges were invoiced separately. The markup was calculated on the part cost alone. So on most transactions, the shipping ate the margin. Every number in the system was accurate. Nothing in the system added them together.
Nobody had hidden anything. The part cost lived in procurement, the courier bill lived in finance, and the customs delays lived at the border. Each department saw its own line. Nobody saw the sum.
2003: The same finding, a different company
In 2003, when the Ottawa Business Journal profiled my company at the time, E-Procure Solutions, I described the market we were serving in almost the same terms: high-tech companies were spending so much time chasing replacement parts that the process of getting a part often cost more than the part itself.
Different company, different year, same gap between price and cost.
2026: Still here
Now it is 2026. We have cloud platforms, real-time analytics and AI agents that can place orders on their own. And a practitioner with a clear view of the market is still having to explain to procurement teams that the price is not the cost.
That is not a criticism of Adriana’s article. It is the reason her article matters. The gap between price and cost is not a problem one generation of technology solves and the next one forgets. It is a constant. It comes back with every new system, because every new system is built on the same documents: the purchase order, the invoice, the quote. The hidden costs live between those documents, in the seams.
What her model does, and what lies beneath it
Adriana’s answer is practical, and it works. Build a simple landed cost model, one row per cost element. Where you don’t have a number, write down a stated assumption instead of leaving a blank. Apply the same assumptions to every supplier. Most important, build it before the negotiation, not after the invoice, so that payment terms, order size and quality become negotiating topics alongside price.
There is one more layer underneath, and it starts with how prices behave.
In 2007, I wrote in Dangerous Supply Chain Myths (Part 7) that commodities fall into one of two patterns. A Historic Flat Line commodity holds a steady price over long periods, with a narrow gap between its lowest and highest price. Direct materials and specialty equipment behave this way. A Dynamic Flux commodity swings sharply and keeps drifting down over time, with a wide gap between its floor and its ceiling. MRO and other indirect materials behave this way. Flat-line commodities usually account for about 80 percent of an organization’s spend and 10 percent of its procurement cycle time. Flux commodities account, on average, for 15 to 20 percent of spend and 90 percent of the cycle time.
The trouble starts when both are bought the same way. A contract price negotiated at signing works for a flat-line item, because the market stays close to it. For a flux item, the market keeps falling away beneath the contract, until the contract price sits above the market’s own ceiling. That is why buyers so often say they can beat the contract price with one phone call to a local supplier.
And within a single day, a flux item can be bought near its floor or near its ceiling. 1998 showed us what decides which one you get.
At DND, the same part from the same supplier could cost up to nine times as much when it was ordered at 4 p.m. as when it was ordered at 9 a.m. The reason was not on any quote. The service technicians were measured on call volume, and stopping to order a part interrupted a service call, so they held their part orders until late afternoon. By then, the suppliers’ day was nearly over, the courier cutoffs were close, and the price and the delivery both suffered.
No landed cost model would have found that cost, because it didn’t belong to any supplier. Every quote carried it equally. The ranking of suppliers was right. The total was wrong.
So there are three tiers. The obvious costs sit on documents someone already receives. The hidden costs, which Adriana lays out, are real and quantifiable but attached to no single document. And beneath both are the costs created by how and when the organization buys. Her model makes the first two visible before the negotiation. Tracing back from the outcome finds the third.
The question to take back
Pick one category you buy every week. What does it cost you, not what is it priced at, and which part of that cost doesn’t appear on any document?
If the answer surprises you, you are in good company. It surprised SHL SystemHouse in 1998. It is still surprising teams in 2026.
Truth Is Believing. Accuracy Is Knowing. Outcome Is Proof.™
-30-
Share this:
Like this:
Related