Here are two of the comments that have already come in:
“Interesting. My view (coming from the private sector)- not everything needs a full-blown RFP. There should be internal guidelines in place outlining when to RFP vs not (based on spend, criticality, risk, outcomes expected, etc).” – Laura Barrett
“Critical to getting a high-quality response to an RFP is Pre Market Engagement (PME). PME is not only an opportunity to warm up the market but also ensuring that any issued RFP can be met, specifications and conditions are fit for purpose and the opportunity to add innovation into the procurement and Contract and Supplier management process .” – David Turner
As you read today’s post, I want you to remember the above comments.
What If?
Everyone is talking about AI these days, be it generative, agentic, or the next-generation version of both—and yes, there is a next-generation AI on the not-too-distant horizon.
With that in mind, I wanted to experiment using the 4 model AI framework.
To start, I selected a prospective practitioner-client—in this case, Byrne Dairy and ProcureTech solution provider AdaptOne.
I then posed the following questions:
How could ProcureTech solution provider AdaptOne help Byrne Dairy?
What would a mock RFP (Request for Proposal) show how Byrne could approach AdaptOne for a pilot program?
What would be the best way for AdaptOne to respond to the Byrne Dairy Mock RFP, e.g., answer the questions in the RFP?
ANSWER #1
AdaptOne could provide significant value to Byrne Dairy, a food and beverage company, by optimizing and digitizing its procurement operations — particularly in supplier management, compliance tracking, and procurement workflow visibility. Here’s how:
🧾 1. Streamlined Supplier Onboarding & Management
Challenge at Byrne Dairy: Managing multiple suppliers for ingredients, packaging, logistics, and equipment — often across regulatory boundaries (FDA, USDA, etc.).
AdaptOne Solution:
Centralized supplier portal with automated onboarding
Real-time tracking of certifications, insurance, NDAs, and regulatory documents
Automated alerts for expiring documents or compliance issues
✅ Impact: Fewer manual processes, reduced supplier risk, faster onboarding, and improved compliance with food safety standards.
📊 2. Enhanced Visibility into Procurement Data
Challenge: Lack of a unified view across departments (purchasing, logistics, quality control).
AdaptOne Solution:
Custom dashboards and reporting tools
Visibility into supplier performance, cycle times, and bottlenecks
Track cost savings, on-time delivery, and non-compliance events
Challenge: Ensuring that all suppliers are compliant with food safety regulations (e.g., HACCP, FSMA, GFSI).
AdaptOne Solution:
Digital document library for supplier certifications
Workflow triggers based on compliance status
Audit readiness through traceable documentation
✅ Impact: Reduced risk of supply chain interruptions and non-compliance penalties.
🤝 5. Integration with Existing Systems
If Byrne Dairy uses Oracle WMS (LogFire) or other systems (e.g., ERP, inventory), AdaptOne’s platform can integrate via APIs to ensure procurement data flows seamlessly.
✅ Impact: Centralized procurement ecosystem, data consistency, and reduced duplication.
🧠 Summary: Why AdaptOne is a Strategic Fit for Byrne Dairy
Byrne Dairy Need
AdaptOne Capability
Supplier risk & compliance tracking
Automated document management, audit trails
Streamlined procurement workflow
No-code workflow automation
Visibility into procurement performance
Dashboards & real-time analytics
Regulatory & food safety compliance
Certification tracking & alerts
Integration with existing systems
Configurable API integrations
ANSWER #2
Here’s a mock RFP (Request for Proposal) that Byrne Dairy could issue to AdaptOne (or other ProcureTech solution providers) for a Procurement Automation and Supplier Management Platform. This template is tailored for a mid-sized food and beverage company with regulatory oversight and a mix of direct and indirect spend.
Issued by: Byrne Dairy, Inc. Date: [Insert Date] Response Deadline: [Insert Deadline, e.g., April 30, 2025] Contact:procurement@byrnedairy.com
1. RFP Purpose
Byrne Dairy is seeking a ProcureTech solution to digitize and streamline its procurement operations. We aim to improve supplier onboarding, ensure regulatory compliance (e.g., USDA, FDA, FSMA), and gain end-to-end visibility into procurement performance across both direct and indirect spend.
2. Company Background
Byrne Dairy is a fourth-generation, family-owned dairy company headquartered in Central New York. We produce milk, yogurt, and other dairy products for retail and food service. Our procurement team manages purchasing for raw materials, packaging, equipment, indirect services, and contract manufacturing.
3. Objectives
We are looking for a scalable, cloud-based solution that will:
Automate and standardize supplier onboarding and qualification
Great question. For AdaptOne to stand out and win Byrne Dairy’s business, the best way to respond to the RFP is through a clear, customer-centric proposal that directly maps AdaptOne’s strengths to Byrne’s stated needs. Here’s a strategic outline AdaptOne could follow, including sample answers and positioning advice for key RFP sections:
✅ AdaptOne Response Strategy to Byrne Dairy Mock RFP
1. Executive Summary
“AdaptOne is a leading provider of supplier onboarding and procurement automation solutions purpose-built for highly regulated industries like food and beverage. Our cloud-native platform empowers organizations like Byrne Dairy to digitize and streamline procurement operations while maintaining full compliance with USDA, FDA, and FSMA requirements.”
Key message: Align with Byrne’s mission of quality, compliance, and operational efficiency.
2. Functional Fit (25%)
What Byrne Asked: Automation of supplier onboarding, document management, procurement workflows, and dashboards.
AdaptOne Response:
Supplier Portal: Fully customizable with branded UI, document capture, electronic signature, and automated workflows.
Workflow Engine: No-code configuration for approvals, RFQ routing, and vendor requalification.
Dashboards: Prebuilt and custom dashboards for procurement KPIs, supplier risk scores, cycle times, and spend visibility.
3. Ease of Integration (20%)
What Byrne Asked: Integration with Oracle WMS (LogFire), Microsoft Office, and SSO.
AdaptOne Response:
API-first architecture supports real-time and batch integrations.
Prebuilt connectors and experience integrating with Oracle WMS (LogFire) and standard ERP systems.
SSO: Supports SAML, Azure AD, and Okta.
💡 Tip: Provide a visual showing past integrations with similar systems in manufacturing or food & beverage.
4. Compliance Support (15%)
What Byrne Asked: Track and manage USDA/FDA/GFSI certifications.
AdaptOne Response:
Custom compliance fields tied to supplier types.
Auto-reminders for expiring documents.
Real-time audit trails and compliance dashboards.
📎 Attach sample screenshots or mock compliance workflows.
5. Usability & UX (10%)
AdaptOne Response:
Modern, intuitive interface designed for non-technical users.
Mobile-ready supplier interface.
High user adoption rate reported by customers in the food and beverage sector.
📣 Include a customer quote from a client in a similar industry.
6. Scalability & Configurability (10%)
AdaptOne Response:
Configurable to handle Byrne’s current scale and future growth across locations or categories.
Role-based workflows and form logic built without IT support.
7. Pricing & Licensing Model (10%)
AdaptOne Response:
Transparent, modular pricing (by supplier volume or user count).
No hidden fees for integrations or upgrades.
Optional managed services (e.g., onboarding support, data migration).
📊 Include a table outlining pricing tiers.
8. Vendor Experience & References (10%)
AdaptOne Response:
10+ years of supplier management experience.
Trusted by manufacturers, distributors, and food industry clients.
Reference accounts available upon request (under NDA).
Bonus Value-Adds
AI-based duplicate vendor detection
Supplier diversity tracking
ESG data collection
📎 Attachments:
One-pager on food and beverage use cases
Integration architecture diagram
Sample workflow + compliance dashboard
Timeline: 6–8 week implementation estimate
IMPORTANT THINGS TO CONSIDER
In early testing, the correlation of multiple AI source answers using a 4-model consolidation framework provides enough source diversity to increase the accuracy of the output. However, as I have emphasized in previous posts like Human With AI, Not Human Versus AI, human experience and expertise must govern the decision-making process.
Also, note that the corresponding algorithms must be tested even more rigorously as you expand the AI source model to include more information sources.
REVISITING THE TWO EARLIER COMMENTS
“Interesting. My view (coming from the private sector)- not everything needs a full-blown RFP. There should be internal guidelines in place outlining when to RFP vs not (based on spend, criticality, risk, outcomes expected, etc).” – Laura Barrett
“Critical to getting a high-quality response to an RFP is Pre Market Engagement (PME). PME is not only an opportunity to warm up the market but also ensuring that any issued RFP can be met, specifications and conditions are fit for purpose and the opportunity to add innovation into the procurement and Contract and Supplier management process .” – David Turner
In the context of the above excerpts from the two comments referenced at the beginning of this post, you can see how humans can work with AI to streamline the RFP intelligence-gathering process to initially identify the right suppliers without having to engage them in a full-blown RFI/RFP process.
ONE FINAL THOUGHT
One of the biggest challenges, especially with public sector RFPs, is the belief that 80% of the business ultimately goes to 20% of the participating suppliers. As a result, many SMEs will not respond to RFP notifications because of the time and resource investment they would have to make in which there is virtually no likelihood they will win.
An “AI Smart” supplier RFP response capability would likely reduce cycle times significantly and dramatically increase participation. That is a discussion for another post.
Procurement Insights 
The Power Of “What If” or “Mock” RFPs
Posted on March 25, 2025
0
Yesterday’s post, “Is It Really The End Of The RFP Process As We Know It?“ inspired a few very insightful comments that lead perfectly into today’s follow-up post.
Here are two of the comments that have already come in:
“Interesting. My view (coming from the private sector)- not everything needs a full-blown RFP. There should be internal guidelines in place outlining when to RFP vs not (based on spend, criticality, risk, outcomes expected, etc).” – Laura Barrett
“Critical to getting a high-quality response to an RFP is Pre Market Engagement (PME). PME is not only an opportunity to warm up the market but also ensuring that any issued RFP can be met, specifications and conditions are fit for purpose and the opportunity to add innovation into the procurement and Contract and Supplier management process .” – David Turner
As you read today’s post, I want you to remember the above comments.
What If?
Everyone is talking about AI these days, be it generative, agentic, or the next-generation version of both—and yes, there is a next-generation AI on the not-too-distant horizon.
With that in mind, I wanted to experiment using the 4 model AI framework.
To start, I selected a prospective practitioner-client—in this case, Byrne Dairy and ProcureTech solution provider AdaptOne.
I then posed the following questions:
ANSWER #1
AdaptOne could provide significant value to Byrne Dairy, a food and beverage company, by optimizing and digitizing its procurement operations — particularly in supplier management, compliance tracking, and procurement workflow visibility. Here’s how:
🧾 1. Streamlined Supplier Onboarding & Management
✅ Impact: Fewer manual processes, reduced supplier risk, faster onboarding, and improved compliance with food safety standards.
📊 2. Enhanced Visibility into Procurement Data
✅ Impact: Informed procurement decisions, better cross-functional collaboration, and spend optimization.
🔄 3. Workflow Automation for Procurement & Sourcing
✅ Impact: Increased speed, fewer errors, lower administrative overhead.
🔒 4. Regulatory & Food Safety Compliance Support
✅ Impact: Reduced risk of supply chain interruptions and non-compliance penalties.
🤝 5. Integration with Existing Systems
✅ Impact: Centralized procurement ecosystem, data consistency, and reduced duplication.
🧠 Summary: Why AdaptOne is a Strategic Fit for Byrne Dairy
ANSWER #2
Here’s a mock RFP (Request for Proposal) that Byrne Dairy could issue to AdaptOne (or other ProcureTech solution providers) for a Procurement Automation and Supplier Management Platform. This template is tailored for a mid-sized food and beverage company with regulatory oversight and a mix of direct and indirect spend.
🧾 Mock RFP: Procurement Automation & Supplier Management Platform
Issued by: Byrne Dairy, Inc.
Date: [Insert Date]
Response Deadline: [Insert Deadline, e.g., April 30, 2025]
Contact: procurement@byrnedairy.com
1. RFP Purpose
Byrne Dairy is seeking a ProcureTech solution to digitize and streamline its procurement operations. We aim to improve supplier onboarding, ensure regulatory compliance (e.g., USDA, FDA, FSMA), and gain end-to-end visibility into procurement performance across both direct and indirect spend.
2. Company Background
Byrne Dairy is a fourth-generation, family-owned dairy company headquartered in Central New York. We produce milk, yogurt, and other dairy products for retail and food service. Our procurement team manages purchasing for raw materials, packaging, equipment, indirect services, and contract manufacturing.
3. Objectives
We are looking for a scalable, cloud-based solution that will:
4. Scope of Work
The selected solution provider should deliver:
5. Key Evaluation Criteria
6. Proposal Requirements
Please include the following in your response:
7. RFP Timeline
8. Submission Instructions
Please send your full proposal in PDF format to:
Procurement Team
📧 procurement@byrnedairy.com
🕓 Submission deadline: [Insert Date and Time]
ANSWER #3
Great question. For AdaptOne to stand out and win Byrne Dairy’s business, the best way to respond to the RFP is through a clear, customer-centric proposal that directly maps AdaptOne’s strengths to Byrne’s stated needs. Here’s a strategic outline AdaptOne could follow, including sample answers and positioning advice for key RFP sections:
✅ AdaptOne Response Strategy to Byrne Dairy Mock RFP
1. Executive Summary
Key message: Align with Byrne’s mission of quality, compliance, and operational efficiency.
2. Functional Fit (25%)
What Byrne Asked: Automation of supplier onboarding, document management, procurement workflows, and dashboards.
AdaptOne Response:
3. Ease of Integration (20%)
What Byrne Asked: Integration with Oracle WMS (LogFire), Microsoft Office, and SSO.
AdaptOne Response:
4. Compliance Support (15%)
What Byrne Asked: Track and manage USDA/FDA/GFSI certifications.
AdaptOne Response:
5. Usability & UX (10%)
AdaptOne Response:
6. Scalability & Configurability (10%)
AdaptOne Response:
7. Pricing & Licensing Model (10%)
AdaptOne Response:
8. Vendor Experience & References (10%)
AdaptOne Response:
Bonus Value-Adds
📎 Attachments:
IMPORTANT THINGS TO CONSIDER
In early testing, the correlation of multiple AI source answers using a 4-model consolidation framework provides enough source diversity to increase the accuracy of the output. However, as I have emphasized in previous posts like Human With AI, Not Human Versus AI, human experience and expertise must govern the decision-making process.
Also, note that the corresponding algorithms must be tested even more rigorously as you expand the AI source model to include more information sources.
REVISITING THE TWO EARLIER COMMENTS
“Interesting. My view (coming from the private sector)- not everything needs a full-blown RFP. There should be internal guidelines in place outlining when to RFP vs not (based on spend, criticality, risk, outcomes expected, etc).” – Laura Barrett
“Critical to getting a high-quality response to an RFP is Pre Market Engagement (PME). PME is not only an opportunity to warm up the market but also ensuring that any issued RFP can be met, specifications and conditions are fit for purpose and the opportunity to add innovation into the procurement and Contract and Supplier management process .” – David Turner
In the context of the above excerpts from the two comments referenced at the beginning of this post, you can see how humans can work with AI to streamline the RFP intelligence-gathering process to initially identify the right suppliers without having to engage them in a full-blown RFI/RFP process.
ONE FINAL THOUGHT
One of the biggest challenges, especially with public sector RFPs, is the belief that 80% of the business ultimately goes to 20% of the participating suppliers. As a result, many SMEs will not respond to RFP notifications because of the time and resource investment they would have to make in which there is virtually no likelihood they will win.
An “AI Smart” supplier RFP response capability would likely reduce cycle times significantly and dramatically increase participation. That is a discussion for another post.
30
Share this:
Related